| Daniel Schumacher | 1756 | 1759 |
| Helfrecht Schaum | 1759 | 1777 |
| Daniel Lehman | 1777 | 1799 |
| Fredrick Ritze | 1799 | 1803 |
| Daniel Lehman | 1803 | 1810 |
| John Knoske | 1810 | 1839 |
| Daniel Kohler | 1839 | 1851 |
| Gustave Hinterleiter | 1852 | 1856 |
| Frederick Speiker | 1867 | 1876 |
| John J. Cressman | 1877 | 1914 |
| Jacob W. Bittner | 1914 | 1959 |
| John S. Fisher | 1960 | 1963 |
| William Davis | 1963 | 1968 |
| Mark A. Lauchnor | 1968 | 1982 |
| John J. Deiinger | 1983 | 1989 |
| Diane La Fauci (Asst. Pastor) | 1993 | 1999 |
| Dennis S. Ritter | 1990 | 2004 |
| Rev. Mary D. Matz (Interim) | 2004 | 2005 |
| Rev. Guy R. Grube (Interim) | 2005 | 2006 |
| Rev. James L. Dunn (Interim) | 2006 | 2007 |
| Pastor Carl Wenzel | 2007 | Present |